Satisfying, but same same.
It is hard to think of anyone asking Santa this year for yet another iteration of A Christmas Carol. It is harder still to think that anyone expected Johnny Depp’s return to mainstream cinema following a certain degree of social vindication would be a foray into holiday schmaltz. Yet, Ti West’s background in gothic horror serves as an apt vessel to deliver a serviceable Christmas film that turns up the dial on the frights.
Ebenezer Scrooge (Johnny Depp) is a miserly money-lender married to nothing but profit. Mourning the loss of his business partner Jacob Marley (Sir Ian McKellen), Scrooge finds solace in shunning any ounce of generosity in the world. The season’s tidings of those like loyal employee Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint) and pure-hearted nephew Fred (Sam Claflin) are rebuffed in favour of balancing the books. Just as it seems he is headed for an unmemorable end to his time on Earth, a visit from the languishing ghost of Marley heralds the coming of a triptych of spirits to examine his Christmases of past, present, and future. Through one horrifying night, Scrooge revisits the joys of humanity and regains a passion for the spirit of the season.
Even if you aren’t a fan of his, it is hard to deny that Depp has an almost unparalleled skill in character performance, even if the days of Jack Sparrow seem like a distant memory. In a lot of ways, it seems he was destined to take on this role that so many have attempted before him. He brings his unique sense of physical and vocal comedy that balances well with the eponymous surliness of Scrooge. He is, of course, silly at times, but let us not forget that this is a Christmas tale. Choice set and costume design captures the moroseness of a London in the throes of the inequitable industrial revolution, and creates an eerie atmosphere that emphasises the ghost story elements more than other iterations of this timeless story.
When viewed in this way, Ebenezer feels reminiscent of Depp’s earlier collaborations with Tim Burton. In a sense, the sentiment for much of the runtime is more akin to the whimsy of The Nightmare Before Christmas. It does make the payoff of Scrooge’s transformation all the more satisfying, but it is ultimately nothing we have not seen before.